Profitability and liquidity: Why a profitable business can have a cash deficit

Ανάλυση οικονομικών καταστάσεων με αριθμομηχανή και σημειώσεις στο γραφείο

Automatic translation · Read the original

A business may show profits at the end of the month and need additional funds to cover its payroll, suppliers or loan installments. To understand how this discrepancy arises, we need to look at three figures together: the accounting result, the cash flow of the period and the liabilities due in the near future.

The accrual principle and cash flow

According to the accrual principle, the effects of transactions are recognized in the period in which they arise. Thus, a sale on credit can increase revenue and receivables from customers today, while collection will increase the available in a later period. The same time distance can exist between the recognition of an expense and its payment. [1]

The International Accounting Standard 7 distinguishes cash flows into operational, investment and financial. In the indirect method of presenting operating flows, the accounting result is adjusted, among other things, for changes in inventories, operating receivables and liabilities, as well as for non-cash items such as depreciation. This analysis helps to explain why the change in cash can differ significantly from the profit for the period. [2]

Five Cases That Explain the Difference

TransactionImpact on accounting result and cash equivalents
Selling on creditWhen the conditions for recognition of revenue are met, the sale is posted and a claim is created by the customer. Cash increases upon collection. [1]
Purchase and Redeem InventoryRepayment reduces the holdings, while the goods are recognized as inventory. At the time of sale, the book value of the goods sold is recognized as an expense. [1, 3]
Fixed asset purchase and depreciationThe repayment of the equipment causes an outflow during payment. Depreciation allocates the depreciable amount over the useful life of the fixed asset, without a corresponding outflow in each period. [1, 2, 4]
Repayment of loan principalThe payment of the amortization reduces the cash and the debt obligation. The effect of interest on the result is considered separately from the repayment of the principal. [2]
Payment of dividendsThe payment of dividends reduces the cash. The distribution concerns the net worth and does not charge the result of the period in which the payment is made as an expense. [1, 2]

The Cash Conversion Cycle and Working Capital

For a commercial enterprise, the need for financing depends largely on the interval between the supplier's payment and the customer's collection. The Cash Conversion Cycle (cash conversion cycle) estimates this duration. It shall be calculated by adding the average days of holding stock and the average days of receivables collection and subtracting the average days of repayment of suppliers. [5, 6]

For example, with 45 days of stock, 60 collection days and 30 days of credit from suppliers, the circle is formed in 75 days. If sales increase and credit conditions remain the same, the firm may need to finance a larger volume of stocks and receivables over the same period. In a study 1.009 large Belgian non-financial firms, Deloof identified a link between profitability and the duration of holding stocks and receivables. The study is sample and period-specific, so a firm's valuation needs to take into account the industry, seasonality and its own trading conditions. [6]

From profit to decrease in cash

In the following hypothetical example, an enterprise displays Profits €25.000. The increase in receivables and inventories absorbs part of the operating flows. Subsequently, the purchase of equipment and the repayment of a loan lead to an overall reduction in reserves. For the sake of simplification, we consider that there are no more cash flow or accounting adjustments. The agreement follows the logic of the IAS indirect method 7. [2]

Period itemAmount
Accounting earnings€25.000
Add depreciation+€5.000
Increase demands from customers−€18.000
Increase in stocks−€12.000
Increase in liabilities to suppliers+€7.000
Net operating cash flow+€7.000
Payment for the purchase of equipment−€10.000
Repayment of loan principal−€4.000
Net change in reserves−€7.000

How liquidity is assessed in practice

The reconciliation of the accounting result with the cash flow explains Why have the available funds changed?. The cash flow forecast answers the next question: When can a deficit occur and how much will it be? The forecast starts from today's cash and places expected receipts and payments in the week they are estimated to occur. A test with a delay in key receipts or higher supplier payments shows how sensitive the business is to a deviation from its planning.

Contact Now with the CK Accounting & Tax Services to examine where your business's cash is tied up and to make a cash flow forecast based on your actual receipts and liabilities.

Sources and bibliography

  1. ELTE. Accounting Directive for the implementation of Law 4308/2014, articles 17, 18, 20 and 25. Accounting Directive
  2. IFRS Foundation. IAS 7 — Statement of Cash Flows, in particular par. 14–20 for the classification of flows and the indirect method. IAS 7
  3. IFRS Foundation. IAS 2 — Inventories, par. 34 for the recognition of the cost of the stocks sold. IAS 2
  4. IFRS Foundation. IAS 16 — Property, Plant and Equipment, par. 50 for the allocation of the depreciable amount to the useful life of the fixed asset. IAS 16
  5. Richards, V. D., & Laughlin, E. J. (1980). A Cash Conversion Cycle Approach to Liquidity Analysis. Financial Management, 9(1), 32–38. DOI
  6. Deloof, M. (2003). Does Working Capital Management Affect Profitability of Belgian Firms? Journal of Business https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-5957.00008Finance & Accounting, 30(3–4), 573–588. DOI

More articles